Verse-by-Verse Commentary
The Book of Jeremiah
Chapter 42: Whether It Be Good, or Whether It Be Evil
The frightened remnant, camped on the road toward Egypt, comes to Jeremiah with what sounds like the perfect prayer. They ask him to seek the LORD for them and vow, 'Whether it be good, or whether it be evil, we will obey the voice of the LORD our God.' After ten days of waiting, God's answer comes, and it is full of grace: stay in the land, and I will build you and plant you; do not fear the king of Babylon, 'for I am with you to save you.' But God also warns them not to go to Egypt, where the very sword and famine they are fleeing will overtake them. Then Jeremiah exposes the fatal flaw beneath their pious words: 'ye dissembled in your hearts.' They had already made up their minds before they ever prayed. This is a searching chapter about seeking God's will honestly, and the danger of asking for guidance we never intend to follow.
About This Commentary
This is a verse-by-verse study of Jeremiah chapter 42. For each section you will find the KJV text, the Hebrew words that sharpen the meaning, plain explanation, and a Gospel Focus. Here God gives a gracious answer to a prayer that was never sincere, and warns against fleeing His will. Every Scripture quotation is from the King James Version.
Setting the Stage
We Will Obey
The remnant asks Jeremiah to pray and vows to obey whatever God says, good or evil.
I Am With You to Save You
God says: stay, and I will build you; fear not the king of Babylon, for I am with you.
Egypt Will Not Save
The sword and famine they flee will overtake them in the very Egypt they run to.
Ye Dissembled in Your Hearts
Their minds were already made up; they asked for guidance they never meant to follow.
We Will Obey the Voice of the LORD (Jeremiah 42:1-6)
The whole remnant comes to Jeremiah, asks him to pray for God's guidance, and solemnly vows to obey whatever the LORD answers, whether it pleases them or not.
Whether It Be Good, or Whether It Be Evil
"Then all the captains of the forces, and Johanan the son of Kareah, and Jezaniah the son of Hoshaiah, and all the people from the least even unto the greatest, came near, And said unto Jeremiah the prophet, Let, we beseech thee, our supplication be accepted before thee, and pray for us unto the LORD thy God, even for all this remnant; (for we are left but a few of many, as thine eyes do behold us:) That the LORD thy God may shew us the way wherein we may walk, and the thing that we may do. Then Jeremiah the prophet said unto them, I have heard you; behold, I will pray unto the LORD your God according to your words; and it shall come to pass, that whatsoever thing the LORD shall answer you, I will declare it unto you; I will keep nothing back from you. Then they said to Jeremiah, The LORD be a true and faithful witness between us, if we do not even according to all things for the which the LORD thy God shall send thee to us. Whether it be good, or whether it be evil, we will obey the voice of the LORD our God, to whom we send thee; that it may be well with us, when we obey the voice of the LORD our God."
Hebrew Study
"shew us the way wherein we may walk," ha-derekh asher nelekh-bah (הַדֶּרֶךְ אֲשֶׁר נֵלֶךְ־בָּהּ). To ask God for "the way" is, on its face, a good and humble prayer, the very cry of a heart seeking guidance (Psalm 143:8). The tragedy of this chapter is not the words of the request, which are excellent, but the heart behind them, which had already chosen its own way.
"whether it be good, or whether it be evil, we will obey," (אִם־טוֹב וְאִם־רָע). The perfect vow of surrender, promising to obey God's word even when it is unwelcome ("evil" here meaning hard or unpleasant to them, not morally wrong). This is exactly the right posture, and exactly what they failed to do, which is why the words become a witness against them.
Explanation
The whole remnant, "from the least even unto the greatest," comes to Jeremiah with what sounds like model piety. They ask him to pray, humbly acknowledging their weakness, "we are left but a few of many," and they frame the request beautifully: "that the LORD thy God may shew us the way wherein we may walk, and the thing that we may do." Jeremiah agrees wholeheartedly and promises complete honesty: "whatsoever thing the LORD shall answer you, I will declare it unto you; I will keep nothing back from you." Then the people make the strongest possible vow, calling God Himself as witness: "The LORD be a true and faithful witness between us, if we do not even according to all things for the which the LORD thy God shall send thee to us. Whether it be good, or whether it be evil, we will obey the voice of the LORD our God." On the surface this is faith at its finest, seeking God's will and pledging unconditional obedience before the answer even comes. But the chapter will reveal that these fine words masked hearts already set on Egypt. They wanted God's blessing on a decision they had already made, not God's direction for a decision still open. The prayer was right; the heart was not.
Gospel Focus
On its face this is how we ought to pray: "shew us the way," and "whether it be good, or whether it be evil, we will obey." Genuine guidance begins with surrender before the answer, a heart that says yes to God's will while it is still unknown. Jesus prayed the true version of this in Gethsemane: "not my will, but thine, be done" (Luke 22:42). But the coming verses expose a subtle and deadly danger, seeking God's guidance when our minds are already made up. It is possible to say all the right words, even to vow obedience with God as witness, while inwardly determined to do our own thing and merely hoping God will bless it. That is not seeking God's will; it is seeking God's signature. The test of real surrender is simple: are you willing to obey the answer before you know what it is? If you will only obey God when His answer matches what you already wanted, you are not submitting to Him, you are using Him. James warns that such a double-minded man "let not that man think that he shall receive any thing of the Lord" (James 1:7-8). Come to God with open hands, truly ready for "whether good or evil," and mean it, for the promise attached is real: "that it may be well with us, when we obey the voice of the LORD our God."
I Am With You to Save You (Jeremiah 42:7-12)
After ten days God answers with grace: if the remnant will stay in the land, He will build and plant them; they need not fear the king of Babylon, for God is with them to save them and to move even the conqueror to show them mercy.
I Will Build You, and Not Pull You Down
"And it came to pass after ten days, that the word of the LORD came unto Jeremiah. Then called he Johanan the son of Kareah, and all the captains of the forces which were with him, and all the people from the least even to the greatest, And said unto them, Thus saith the LORD, the God of Israel, unto whom ye sent me to present your supplication before him; If ye will still abide in this land, then will I build you, and not pull you down, and I will plant you, and not pluck you up: for I repent me of the evil that I have done unto you. Be not afraid of the king of Babylon, of whom ye are afraid; be not afraid of him, saith the LORD: for I am with you to save you, and to deliver you from his hand. And I will shew mercies unto you, that he may have mercy upon you, and cause you to return to your own land."
Hebrew Study
"then will I build you... and I will plant you," u-vanithi... ve-natati (וּבָנִיתִי ... וְנָטָעְתִּי). The very verbs of Jeremiah's original commission, to "build, and to plant" (Jeremiah 1:10). The God who had uprooted them for judgment now offers to replant them in mercy. His purpose was never mere destruction but restoration for those who would trust and obey.
"for I repent me of the evil," ki nichamti (כִּי נִחַמְתִּי). God "repents", relents, turns from, the disaster He had brought, not because He changes His nature but because His disposition toward a humbled people turns from judgment to mercy (compare Jeremiah 18:8; Joel 2:13). His readiness to relent is the open door of grace held out to the remnant.
Explanation
Jeremiah waits "ten days" for God's answer, no instant word, but a real seeking that took patience. When it comes, the answer is overflowing with grace. "If ye will still abide in this land, then will I build you, and not pull you down, and I will plant you, and not pluck you up." The remnant's whole future is offered on one condition: stay where God has placed you. God even says, "I repent me of the evil that I have done unto you", the season of judgment is over for those who will remain and trust Him. He addresses their exact fear head-on: "Be not afraid of the king of Babylon, of whom ye are afraid; be not afraid of him," and gives the reason that answers all fear, "for I am with you to save you, and to deliver you from his hand." More than mere safety, God promises to turn the conqueror's heart toward them: "I will shew mercies unto you, that he may have mercy upon you." Everything they were afraid of, God promised to handle if they would simply obey and stay. It was a stunning offer of protection, restoration, and mercy, freely given to a defeated and frightened people. All they had to do was believe it and stay put.
Gospel Focus
"Be not afraid... for I am with you to save you." This is the answer God gives to every fear that would drive us out of His will. The remnant's terror was understandable, but God met it not with a strategy but with His presence: "I am with you." The same promise runs through all Scripture, "Fear thou not; for I am with thee" (Isaiah 41:10), and reaches its height in the name of Christ, "Emmanuel... God with us" (Matthew 1:23), and His parting word, "lo, I am with you alway" (Matthew 28:20). When God is with us to save, no earthly power we fear can finally harm us; "if God be for us, who can be against us?" (Romans 8:31). Notice, too, that God's protection came with a place to stand: "abide in this land." His safety is found in the place of obedience, not in the refuge our fear invents. And see the astonishing reach of His grace, He would even "shew mercies unto you, that he may have mercy upon you," turning the heart of the very king they dreaded, for "the king's heart is in the hand of the LORD" (Proverbs 21:1). Whatever you fear today, God's answer is not merely "it will be fine," but "I am with you to save you." Believe Him, stay in the place of obedience, and let His presence, not your fear, decide your course.
Ye Dissembled in Your Hearts (Jeremiah 42:13-22)
God warns that if they flee to Egypt, the very sword and famine they fear will follow them there and destroy them; then Jeremiah exposes that their prayer was never sincere, for they had already resolved to go.
The Sword, Which Ye Feared, Shall Overtake You There
"But if ye say, We will not dwell in this land, neither obey the voice of the LORD your God, Saying, No; but we will go into the land of Egypt, where we shall see no war, nor hear the sound of the trumpet, nor have hunger of bread; and there will we dwell: And now therefore hear the word of the LORD, ye remnant of Judah; Thus saith the LORD of hosts, the God of Israel; If ye wholly set your faces to enter into Egypt, and go to sojourn there; Then it shall come to pass, that the sword, which ye feared, shall overtake you there in the land of Egypt, and the famine, whereof ye were afraid, shall follow close after you there in Egypt; and there ye shall die. So shall it be with all the men that set their faces to go into Egypt to sojourn there; they shall die by the sword, by the famine, and by the pestilence: and none of them shall remain or escape from the evil that I will bring upon them. For thus saith the LORD of hosts, the God of Israel; As mine anger and my fury hath been poured forth upon the inhabitants of Jerusalem; so shall my fury be poured forth upon you, when ye shall enter into Egypt: and ye shall be an execration, and an astonishment, and a curse, and a reproach; and ye shall see this place no more. The LORD hath said concerning you, O ye remnant of Judah; Go ye not into Egypt: know certainly that I have admonished you this day. For ye dissembled in your hearts, when ye sent me unto the LORD your God, saying, Pray for us unto the LORD our God; and according unto all that the LORD our God shall say, so declare unto us, and we will do it. And now I have this day declared it to you; but ye have not obeyed the voice of the LORD your God, nor any thing for the which he hath sent me unto you. Now therefore know certainly that ye shall die by the sword, by the famine, and by the pestilence, in the place whither ye desire to go and to sojourn."
Hebrew Study
"ye dissembled in your hearts," hit'etem be-nafshoteikhem (הִתְעֵיתֶם בְּנַפְשׁוֹתֵיכֶם). The verb carries the sense of leading astray or deceiving; here reflexively, "ye deceived your own selves." Their insincere prayer did not fool God, and in the end it deceived no one but themselves. Self-deception is the deadly heart of asking God for guidance one has no intention of following.
"the sword, which ye feared, shall overtake you there," (הַחֶרֶב אֲשֶׁר אַתֶּם יְרֵאִים). A piercing irony: the very dangers they fled to Egypt to escape, war and famine, would chase them down in Egypt itself. What we run to in disobedience becomes the place of the very thing we feared. There is no safe hiding place outside the will of God.
Explanation
God anticipates their real intention: "if ye say, We will not dwell in this land... but we will go into the land of Egypt, where we shall see no war... nor have hunger of bread." Egypt looked like security. But God's warning is devastating and ironic: "the sword, which ye feared, shall overtake you there in the land of Egypt, and the famine, whereof ye were afraid, shall follow close after you there in Egypt; and there ye shall die." The very disasters they fled would hunt them down in their chosen refuge. Worse, the fury poured out on Jerusalem would be poured out on them too, and they would become "an execration, and an astonishment, and a curse," never to see their homeland again. Then Jeremiah lays bare the truth beneath their pious request: "For ye dissembled in your hearts, when ye sent me unto the LORD." They had never intended to obey; they wanted approval, not direction. "I have this day declared it to you; but ye have not obeyed the voice of the LORD your God." The verdict is certain: if they go, "ye shall die by the sword, by the famine, and by the pestilence, in the place whither ye desire to go." They asked for the way; they were given it plainly; and they had already decided to reject it.
Gospel Focus
"Ye dissembled in your hearts." This is the sober warning at the center of the chapter: it is possible to go through every motion of seeking God, prayer, spiritual language, even a solemn vow, while the heart has already decided against Him. Such prayer deceives no one but ourselves. "Be not deceived; God is not mocked" (Galatians 6:7), and "the LORD searcheth all hearts, and understandeth all the imaginations of the thoughts" (1 Chronicles 28:9). God is not fooled by religious words laid over a rebellious will. The chapter also teaches that there is no safe refuge outside the will of God. The remnant thought Egypt meant "no war... no hunger," but the very things they feared would find them there, because "safety" bought by disobedience is an illusion. Jonah learned it fleeing to Tarshish; you cannot outrun God into a better outcome. The safest place in the universe is the center of God's will, however exposed it looks, and the most dangerous is the refuge we choose against His word, however secure it seems. The gospel calls us to real surrender, not the counterfeit that seeks God's blessing on our own plans. Bring God an honest, open heart, willing to obey before you know the answer; and when He shows you the way, walk in it, even if it means staying in a hard land rather than fleeing to a comfortable Egypt. Obedience is the only true safety.
Chapter 42 in Review
Jeremiah 42 is a study in seeking God's will, honestly and dishonestly. The frightened remnant asks Jeremiah to pray and makes the finest of vows: "Whether it be good, or whether it be evil, we will obey the voice of the LORD our God." After ten days God answers with pure grace: stay in the land, and "will I build you, and not pull you down"; "be not afraid of the king of Babylon... for I am with you to save you," promising even to turn the conqueror's heart to mercy. But He warns that if they flee to Egypt, the sword and famine they fear will overtake them there, and they will die. Then Jeremiah names the fatal flaw beneath their piety: "ye dissembled in your hearts." They had already decided to go; they wanted God's blessing, not His guidance.
For the Apostolic reader, this chapter searches the way we pray and the way we fear. True seeking of God's will surrenders before the answer comes, "whether good or evil," as Christ prayed, "not my will, but thine, be done"; anything less is seeking God's signature, not His direction, and such double-minded asking "receives nothing of the Lord." God's answer to fear is not a strategy but His presence, "I am with you to save you," the promise fulfilled in Emmanuel, "God with us," who says "lo, I am with you alway." And there is no safe refuge outside His will: the Egypt we run to in disobedience becomes the place of the very thing we feared. Come to God with an open, honest heart, ready to obey before you know; let His presence, not your fear, choose your road; and remember that the only true safety is the center of His will.
- True seeking of God's will surrenders before the answer: "whether good or evil, we will obey" (42:6; Luke 22:42).
- Asking God to bless a decision already made is seeking His signature, not His guidance (42:20; James 1:7-8).
- God's answer to fear is His presence: "I am with you to save you" (42:11; Isaiah 41:10; Matthew 28:20).
- God relents toward the humble, offering to build and plant those who trust Him (42:10; Jeremiah 1:10; 18:8).
- There is no safe refuge outside God's will; the feared evil follows us into our chosen "Egypt" (42:16).
- God is never fooled by pious words over a rebellious heart (42:20; Galatians 6:7; 1 Chronicles 28:9).
Questions for Reflection
- When you pray for guidance, are you willing to obey the answer before you know what it is?
- Is there a decision where you want God's blessing on a plan you have already made?
- How does "I am with you to save you" speak to the fear that is steering you right now?
- Are you running to an "Egypt" for safety instead of staying in the harder place of obedience?
References & Sources
Scripture is quoted from the King James Version (KJV). The Hebrew terms are standard and can be checked in any Hebrew lexicon. The chapter follows the remnant's flight toward Egypt after Gedaliah's murder (Jeremiah 41). "Shew us the way wherein we may walk" (verse 3) is the language of guidance (Psalm 143:8). "Whether it be good, or whether it be evil, we will obey" (verse 6), true surrender, is modeled by Christ in Luke 22:42. God waited "ten days" (verse 7). the promise to "build you" and "plant you" (verse 10) repeats the verbs of Jeremiah 1:10; "I repent me of the evil" reflects God relenting toward the humble (Jeremiah 18:8; Joel 2:13). "I am with you to save you" (verse 11) runs through Isaiah 41:10; Matthew 1:23; 28:20; Romans 8:31; the turning of the king's heart is Proverbs 21:1. "Ye dissembled in your hearts" (verse 20) exposes insincere prayer (James 1:7-8; Galatians 6:7; 1 Chronicles 28:9). The irony that the feared sword and famine follow them to Egypt (verse 16) recalls that there is no refuge outside God's will (compare Jonah 1). If anything here does not look right, a verse, a reference, or a wording, please tell us at info@FruitBearers.net. Thank you for helping us keep Bible Learning error free.
- The remnant's request and vow to obey: Jeremiah 42:1-6; Psalm 143:8; Luke 22:42; James 1:7-8.
- God's gracious answer, stay and fear not, for I am with you: Jeremiah 42:7-12; Jeremiah 1:10; Isaiah 41:10; Matthew 1:23; 28:20; Proverbs 21:1.
- The warning against Egypt; dissembling hearts exposed: Jeremiah 42:13-22; Galatians 6:7; 1 Chronicles 28:9; Jonah 1.